Yes, it appears that the FDA is indeed intervening in the relationship between craft brewers and farmers regarding the use of spent grain from beer production as feed for cows. Despite no evidence of harm to cows or humans from this practice, the FDA is reportedly concerned and is proposing regulations that would require breweries to dry and package spent grain before it can be given or sold to farmers for use as feed. This interference has sparked criticism from both brewers and farmers, who argue that the proposed rules would impose unnecessary financial burdens and disrupt a beneficial arrangement.
Indeed, one might expect that the FDA would support initiatives that promote recycling and provide a cost-effective solution for farmers, especially when there is no evidence of harm to animals or humans involved. However, regulatory agencies often have specific guidelines and concerns that may not align with common sense or practical benefits. In this case, the FDA’s proposed regulations appear to prioritize certain food safety protocols over the potential benefits of recycling spent grain as feed for livestock.
Those involved seem to be happy according to the report on a local Maine news station.
“”I once was just able feed what they produced to my cattle and it has grown to where I feed cattle across Maine now,” explained Justice, who’s business delivering the feed has grown in lock step with the growth of Allagash Brewing Company.’
The symbiotic relationship between brewers and farmers, where brewers provide spent grain as feed for livestock, indeed appears to be a mutually beneficial arrangement. Brewers can efficiently dispose of their spent grain while reducing waste, and farmers receive a valuable source of feed for their livestock at little to no cost. This symbiosis not only fosters economic efficiency but also promotes sustainability and resourcefulness within the local community.
So what possible excuse do the Feds have for messing this up for farmers and brewers. Reason Magazine has got to the bottom of it and it is dumb as you would imagine.
“Under new rules proposed by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, breweries would be required to dry and package spent grain before it could be given or sold to farmers to use as feed. Both brewers and farmers are upset by the proposal, which they say would pose a big financial burden and also just generally makes no sense.”
The proposed FDA regulations requiring breweries to dry and package spent grain before providing it to farmers could indeed increase operational costs for both brewers and farmers. These additional requirements may lead to higher production costs for breweries, which could potentially be passed on to consumers in the form of higher beer prices. Moreover, farmers may incur expenses associated with the purchase of dried and packaged spent grain, which could impact their bottom line. Overall, these regulatory changes have the potential to disrupt the existing symbiotic relationship between brewers and farmers, resulting in economic challenges for both parties involved.
At least Maine’s Congressional delegation is making noises on this issue in DC.
